Simple Problems in High Conflict Parenting: When More Information Is Not the Answer

Nov 16, 2026By Cori McGuire
Cori McGuire

I have now written 115 articles about separation, parenting after separation, communication, decision-making, mediation and Parenting Coordination. They are free, and many give parents specific tools for resolving ordinary disagreements without paying lawyers, mediators or a Parenting Coordinator. I also provide parents with communication structures and proposal formats intended to help them resolve problems themselves.

Yet some families continue to spend significant amounts of money addressing problems for which they already have plenty of information. The problem is not always that parents do not know what to do. Increasingly, I think we need to consider a different possibility: conflict itself may interfere with the ability to use what people already know.

What if it isn't a knowledge problem?

People experiencing a difficult separation may simultaneously be managing grief, anger, fear, financial uncertainty, litigation, work, children and an ongoing parenting relationship with someone from whom they are trying to separate emotionally. Solving even a fairly ordinary parenting problem in that environment can require a surprising amount of mental work. A parent may have to remember what was previously agreed, separate the current problem from past grievances, consider the other parent's proposal, generate alternatives and decide what will actually work for the child.

Those are also many of the same cognitive tasks we ask people to perform in mediation: absorb new information, consider another perspective, generate options, evaluate proposals and make consequential decisions.

There is scientific reason to think stress can make some of that harder. This does not mean separated parents cannot make good decisions, and it certainly does not mean every difficult communication can be attributed to stress. It does suggest that continually adding information may not always be the most useful response.

A 2016 meta-analysis drawing on 51 studies found a small overall impairment in working memory following experimentally induced acute stress. It also found evidence that acute stress can impair cognitive flexibility, although that part of the analysis was based on only six studies. Working memory and cognitive flexibility are among the executive functions involved in holding information in mind, considering alternatives and changing course when circumstances require it (The Effects of Acute Stress on Core Executive Functions: A Meta-Analysis and Comparison with Cortisol, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5003767/).

That research concerned laboratory-induced acute stress, not the sustained and socially complicated stress of a difficult separation. It also did not study Parenting Coordination clients. Those limitations matter because laboratory findings should not be turned into assumptions about why a particular parent behaves as they do.

More recent research has begun looking at executive functioning in the family context. A 2024 longitudinal study followed 231 cohabiting families with preschool-aged children and examined whether parental executive functioning might help explain how destructive interparental conflict spills over into parenting. Among fathers, interparental conflict predicted later parenting difficulties indirectly through reduced cognitive flexibility, but not through working memory or inhibitory control; the same indirect pathway was not established for mothers (A Process Model of Parental Executive Functioning as a Spillover Mechanism Linking Interparental Conflict and Parenting Difficulties Across Parenting Domains, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11164625/).

Again, the limits matter. That study was not about separated high-conflict parents, and its authors described it as a first step in examining executive functioning as a mechanism linking interparental conflict and parenting difficulties. The useful conclusion for separating families is therefore a modest one: significant stress and conflict may interfere with some of the mental processes required for organized and flexible problem-solving. Sometimes people may have difficulty using information they already possess.

More information may actually be the wrong intervention

The better intervention may be structure. That principle applies whether parents are trying to solve the problem themselves, working with a mediator or participating in Parenting Coordination. One issue at a time, clearly stated proposals, manageable choices and a predictable process can reduce the amount of information parents must organize at once.

The same insight matters in mediation. A mediator does not necessarily help a highly conflicted family by putting every issue on the table at once and inviting an open-ended discussion. Process design may instead require sequencing issues, taking breaks, using separate meetings where appropriate, narrowing the decisions that actually need to be made and working with concrete proposals rather than competing histories of the relationship.

The objective is not to constrain meaningful participation. It is to create conditions in which meaningful participation is more realistically possible. Good process design does not decide the outcome for the parents; it makes the path toward their own decision-making clearer.

Parenting Coordination adds a different dimension. If agreement cannot be reached and the unresolved issue falls within the Parenting Coordinator's jurisdiction, the matter may move from consensus-building to determination rather than another cycle of explanation.

Mediation and Parenting Coordination both benefit from thoughtful process design, but their authority is different. A mediator facilitates the parents' own decision-making and cannot impose the substantive outcome. A Parenting Coordinator may facilitate agreement and, where that authority has actually been conferred, make a binding determination within the scope of that jurisdiction.

There is an important legal distinction here. Structure is not jurisdiction. A Parenting Coordinator's authority derives from the Family Law Act, the Family Law Act Regulation and, critically, the jurisdiction conferred by the particular court order or agreement appointing the Parenting Coordinator including the Parenting Coordination Agreement itself. A structured consultation process may assist parents to resolve a problem, but a binding determination can be made only where authority over that subject matter has actually been conferred.

Make recurring conflict predictable and boring

Consider parenting exchanges. In a persistently conflicted family, parents can end up fighting about where a vehicle stops, who gets out, where somebody stands, which direction somebody walks and precisely when responsibility for the child changes hands. Every little ambiguity becomes another decision to make and potentially another opportunity for disagreement.

Sometimes the practical solution is an extremely specific exchange protocol: a designated location, parking area, time, walking route and transfer procedure. The point is not to decide which parent has won the parking dispute or to regulate parental conduct for its own sake. It is to create a workable way of implementing the parenting arrangement without requiring the parents to negotiate the same details every week.

A good exchange protocol should ultimately make the exchange predictable and boring. Whether parents develop that protocol themselves, negotiate it in mediation or require assistance through Parenting Coordination, the objective is the same: the recurring problem should eventually stop requiring recurring negotiation. Nobody needs to demonstrate control, interpret the other parent's movements or improvise the procedure at every exchange. Ideally, the child simply knows what happens next.

Routine appointments need practical rules too

Medical and dental appointments can create the same recurring conflict. Both parents may legitimately want information about their child's health, but that does not necessarily mean both parents need to physically attend every routine and non-essential appointment. For some families, joint attendance works perfectly well; for others, it creates more difficulty than benefit.

One practical solution may be alternating attendance at routine appointments, with the non-attending parent participating by telephone or video where appropriate and both parents continuing to receive relevant information. Significant or urgent medical issues may obviously require something different. The objective is not to exclude a parent, but to facilitate the exercise of the parents' existing parental responsibilities without recreating the same conflict every time the child has a routine appointment.

Whether a Parenting Coordinator can impose such a protocol as a binding determination is a separate legal question. That depends on the jurisdiction actually conferred by the appointment. The usefulness of an idea does not itself create jurisdiction to impose it.

A sick child should not create a parenting-time bank account

Illness creates another recurring problem. Suppose a seven-year-old becomes genuinely too sick to travel during one parent's parenting time and consequently misses a holiday or weekend with the other parent. Does every missed day automatically become a debt that must later be repaid?

Make-up time may be entirely appropriate, and I generally encourage parents to find a reasonable replacement when meaningful parenting time is lost. But caring for a sick child is also parenting. A parent who spends Thanksgiving looking after a vomiting or feverish child has not necessarily obtained a holiday windfall that automatically entitles the other parent to the next healthy Thanksgiving.

A useful reality check is to reverse the situation. If the child became seriously ill while in the other parent's care, would you insist that the child travel anyway, or would you expect the child to remain where they were until they could comfortably travel? Both parents are capable of looking after their child when the child is ill, and the answer should not depend entirely on which parent happened to have parenting time when the illness began.

Families can establish illness protocols before the next illness

Parents who repeatedly encounter this problem need a protocol, not another historical argument. If a child is said to be too ill to travel, a video call may allow the other parent to see the child's condition, and appropriate medical confirmation may sometimes be useful where reasonably available. There also needs to be common sense about medical confirmation because a child genuinely too ill for substantial travel may also be too ill to be taken to an appointment merely to obtain a note.

Distance may require practical alternatives. A parent may sometimes be able to obtain accommodation near the child and care for the child locally, or ferry-dependent families might agree that the child takes the next reasonably available ferry once well enough to travel. Parents may instead agree in advance on reasonable replacement parenting time.

These are exactly the kinds of proposals parents can discuss themselves for free. They do not need to pay a lawyer, mediator or Parenting Coordinator simply to generate possible solutions they are capable of proposing themselves. Professional assistance may become useful when they cannot reach agreement: mediation can help them negotiate among reasonable alternatives, while a Parenting Coordinator may make a binding determination only where the unresolved issue falls within the jurisdiction conferred by the appointment.

Make-up time should not accumulate indefinitely

When parenting time has been lost and make-up time is appropriate, it should usually be addressed reasonably promptly. One family might adopt a protocol requiring replacement time to be requested and scheduled within 30 days, with an unresolved claim brought forward before 90 days have elapsed or the claim expires. Those periods are simply examples of a structure parents might agree upon; they are not legal rules or time limits that apply generally to parenting time.

Equivalent time also does not necessarily mean identical time. An extended weekend might reasonably replace shorter missed parenting time without adding yet another weekend to an already demanding schedule. What works should take account of the child's age, travel burden, school, activities, relationships and the resulting period away from each parent.

For a seven-year-old, for example, four consecutive weekends involving approximately 25 hours of travel may not be a sensible solution merely because the arithmetic produces a particular number of replacement hours. Nor is a very long absence from the other parent necessarily the answer. Parenting time is not an accounting ledger.

Clear proposals are free

This is the part parents sometimes overlook. You do not need a lawyer, mediator or Parenting Coordinator to make a reasonable proposal to the other parent, and you do not need to raise every disagreement in the abstract and ask a professional to develop the solution. State the issue, provide the relevant dates and times, make a concrete proposal and invite a reasonable alternative before asking a professional to solve the problem for you.

If you have been given a communication format, use it. If you want the Parenting Coordinator to review a particular OFW communication, provide its date and time rather than paying the Parenting Coordinator to search through months of messages. If the process calls for one issue at a time, identify the actual unresolved issue instead of reopening every grievance surrounding it.

Every avoidable step becomes professional time when the Parenting Coordinator has to perform it for the parents. A task that takes a parent thirty seconds may take considerably longer for a professional who first has to locate the material and reconstruct the relevant history. Structure is therefore not bureaucratic housekeeping. It is one of the principal ways to keep Parenting Coordination affordable.

Parenting Coordination also has to be funded

A Parenting Coordination process cannot operate indefinitely without money. If the terms of the appointment require a parent to maintain money in trust, the retainer needs to be maintained so the Parenting Coordinator can actually do the work when a dispute requires professional intervention. Sending additional material for professional review while leaving the required work unfunded is not a sustainable process.

Nor does unlimited unpaid professional work solve the underlying problem. If the process requires parents to identify issues, provide relevant information and maintain any funding required by the appointment, those requirements help create a system in which professional resources are used for the work parents actually require rather than for avoidable reconstruction of the dispute.

Fee allocation is not punishment for disagreeing with the other parent or with the Parenting Coordinator. Where the governing legislation and appointment confer the necessary authority, however, the allocation or reapportionment of fees may address disproportionate use of the Parenting Coordination process and the professional time that use generates. Whether that authority exists must always be determined from the legislation and the particular terms of the appointment.

Sometimes a deadline works better than another explanation

A similar principle applies when consultation has run its course and a matter properly requires determination. Some Parenting Coordination agreements may establish defined funding requirements or deadlines before determination work begins. If, for example, the governing process provides five days to fund the Parenting Coordinator after a matter has properly moved to determination, the significance of the deadline is not that five days is inherently the right period.

The value is predictability. The parents know before the dispute occurs what comes next: consultation, an unresolved issue, any required funding, and then determination where jurisdiction exists. Any such deadline and its consequences must, of course, come from the governing appointment process rather than being invented after a dispute has arisen.

That is the advantage of structure more generally. Parents should not have to renegotiate the procedure for resolving the dispute while simultaneously fighting about the dispute itself. They know what happens next.

Compassion and accountability are not opposites

None of this requires us to assume that separated parents deliberately choose every dysfunctional interaction. Research concerning acute stress and executive functioning gives us legitimate reason to be cautious about the assumption that every repetitive, rigid or ineffective response simply reflects unwillingness to do better.

At the same time, the research does not establish why any particular parent behaved in a particular way. Understanding the possible effects of stress should therefore lead away from shame and blame, but not away from accountability. For mediators and Parenting Coordinators, it should also raise a process-design question: are we asking people to perform unnecessarily complicated cognitive tasks at precisely the time they may find those tasks most difficult? 

If open-ended conflict places greater demands on organized and flexible problem-solving, the sensible response is to make the system easier to navigate. Fewer simultaneous issues, concrete proposals, defined response periods and predictable next steps may accomplish considerably more than another article explaining why everyone should communicate better.

That is an important distinction. Compassion can explain why we build better systems. Accountability means expecting people to use them.

At some point, Parenting Coordination reaches its limit

There is nevertheless a point at which the Parenting Coordinator has to acknowledge that the intervention is not working. If parents have clear instructions, communication structures, proposal templates, accessible educational materials and repeated opportunities to resolve matters themselves, continuing to supply additional information may accomplish very little. The question is no longer simply whether the parents know what to do; it becomes whether the existing process enables them to do it.

Sometimes that exposes a more structural difficulty in the parenting arrangement. If parents remain unable to exercise particular parental responsibilities within the existing allocation of responsibility despite substantial implementation assistance, or if routine decisions repeatedly require paid adjudication, the existing arrangement itself may require reconsideration. Persistent inability to fund or sustain the Parenting Coordination process raises a related but distinct problem: a professional dispute-resolution mechanism cannot function if the resources necessary to operate it are not available.

That does not authorize a Parenting Coordinator to gradually assume powers that were never conferred. Where the necessary solution would change parenting arrangements or parental responsibilities beyond the Parenting Coordinator's jurisdiction, that reconsideration belongs to the court.

For those of us working in the trenches of mediation, Parenting Coordination and other forms of high-conflict family dispute resolution, however, an important question remains: what should replace a decision-making structure that repeatedly produces conflict despite substantial professional assistance?

There is no single answer, and some of the newer approaches being considered are very much works in progress as practitioners, researchers and courts learn more about what these family systems actually need. I discuss the Master Joyce hybrid decision-making approach at Master Joyce Hybrid Parenting Decision-Making, with other developing approaches described at Parenting Coordination Models and Decision-Making.

The boundary is important. Parenting Coordination is an implementation process, and the existence of a difficult family problem does not itself create jurisdiction. Sometimes returning to court is not a failure of Parenting Coordination; it is recognition that implementation assistance cannot repair an underlying arrangement that requires judicial reconsideration. Recognizing when not to keep adding Parenting Coordination is therefore part of using the process responsibly.

Before spending more money on Parenting Coordination

Before sending the next non-urgent disagreement to your Parenting Coordinator, identify one issue and make one concrete proposal. Include the dates, times and practical details needed to implement it, consider any reasonable counterproposal and ask yourself whether you could live with your proposed rule if the parents' positions were reversed. You may discover that the problem can be resolved without professional involvement at all.

If Parenting Coordinator involvement really is required, identify the exact OFW communication by date and time, state the unresolved implementation question and ensure that any funding required by the governing process is in place. Do not pay a professional to locate information you can readily identify yourself or to formulate the first proposal you are capable of making. Those are simple ways parents can substantially reduce the cost of Parenting Coordination.

The goal of Parenting Coordination should not be to create families who become exceptionally good at bringing disputes to a Parenting Coordinator. The same principle applies to mediation. Success is not measured by how frequently a family returns to mediation, but by whether the agreements and structures developed there help the family manage ordinary parenting problems without professional intervention.

A better measure of success is whether parents progressively need less professional intervention because the systems surrounding ordinary parenting problems have become clearer and more predictable. More information does not always produce that result. Sometimes the most effective intervention is a structure simple enough to use when conflict makes everything else harder.

Research note

The research discussed in this article describes group-level experimental findings and associations involving stress, executive functioning, interparental conflict and parenting. It does not establish why a particular parent failed to follow instructions, permit a Parenting Coordinator to diagnose a parent, prove that difficult behaviour results from stress or trauma, or establish that laboratory-induced acute stress is equivalent to the prolonged stress of a difficult separation.

Its practical significance is narrower but still important. Stress and conflict may interfere with some of the mental processes involved in organized and flexible problem-solving. That provides a reason to consider designing family dispute-resolution processes, including mediation and Parenting Coordination, around clarity, manageable steps and predictable procedure rather than assuming that continually supplying more information will necessarily resolve the problem.

Written by Cori L. McGuire, family law mediator, arbitrator, collaborative family law lawyer and Parenting Coordinator with a family law practice in British Columbia since 1998.

© 2026 Cori McGuire. All Rights Reserved.

↩ To return to the original webpage, use your browser's Back button or back arrow.