When PC Agreements are Ignored: Enforcement and Capacity
When Parenting Coordination Agreements Are Not Followed
Parenting Coordination is intended to help separated parents implement the parenting arrangements already established by a court order or agreement. Parents may resolve an implementation issue through consultation, with assistance from the Parenting Coordinator, or through a binding Parenting Coordinator determination where the PC has jurisdiction and agreement cannot be reached. Parenting Coordinators help parents carry out existing arrangements, but cannot fundamentally change them. Most issues that are resolved through Parenting Coordination move forward without further dispute. Sometimes, however, a parent later acts inconsistently with an agreement, order or Parenting Coordinator determination.
What happens next depends on an important distinction: Is there still an implementation problem that the Parenting Coordinator has jurisdiction to address, or does the situation now require enforcement, variation or another form of judicial authority?
A Parenting Coordinator can assist with the first. The second belongs to the court.
Are Parenting Agreements Binding in British Columbia?
It is important to distinguish between whether an agreement is binding and how it may be enforced. Section 6 of British Columbia's Family Law Act provides that, subject to the Act, an agreement respecting a family law dispute is binding on the parties. The Act expressly provides that this is so whether or not the agreement was made with the involvement of a family dispute resolution professional and whether or not it has been filed with a court.
Parenting arrangements are also subject to the specific provisions of Part 4 of the Family Law Act. The legal effect of filing an agreement and the remedies available when an agreement is not followed therefore depend upon the nature of the agreement, the relief being sought and the applicable provisions of the Act.
The important point for Parenting Coordination is simpler: An agreement does not become optional merely because it was reached outside the courtroom or with the assistance of a Parenting Coordinator.
At the same time, a Parenting Coordinator is not a court enforcement officer. The fact that an agreement is binding does not give the PC powers that the Family Law Act, Regulation and governing appointment do not confer.
What Should Parents Do When an Agreement Is Not Followed?
The first response does not necessarily need to be a Parenting Coordinator referral. Where it is safe and appropriate to do so, the most efficient first step may be for one parent to communicate directly with the other parent. Rather than beginning with an accusation that the other parent has breached the agreement, a parent can identify the apparent inconsistency and ask for an explanation or proposal for implementation.
There may be a misunderstanding. Circumstances may have changed. An implementation detail may not have been anticipated. The parents may be able to resolve the problem themselves without incurring further professional fees. That is generally preferable when it works.
If direct consultation does not resolve the issue, the Parenting Coordinator may then be able to assist, depending upon the nature of the dispute and the jurisdiction actually conferred.
Non-Compliance Does Not Automatically End Parenting Coordination
A parent's failure to follow an agreement, order or previous determination does not automatically mean that the issue is now outside Parenting Coordinator jurisdiction. Sometimes the conduct creates a new or continuing implementation dispute.
The Parenting Coordinator may need to identify the operative parenting arrangement, clarify what issue now requires resolution, obtain the information necessary to understand the dispute and determine whether the matter falls within the PC's lawful and delegated jurisdiction. If it does, Parenting Coordination may still provide a useful solution.
For example, an existing provision may establish what is supposed to happen but leave practical details unclear. A recurring implementation problem may demonstrate the need for a more precise process. Two parents may genuinely disagree about how an existing term operates in a new circumstance. Those are potentially implementation questions.
The Parenting Coordinator's task is not to punish the earlier non-compliance. It is to determine whether there is an implementation issue the PC is authorized to help resolve.
Parenting Coordination Is Not Enforcement
This distinction is fundamental. A Parenting Coordinator may assist parents in implementing existing parenting arrangements and, where authorized, make a binding determination resolving an eligible implementation dispute. A PC cannot use that authority to fundamentally change the underlying parenting agreement or order. The PC does not impose judicial sanctions because somebody failed to follow an agreement. Nor should a determination be used simply to declare that one parent behaved badly in the past.
The focus remains forward-looking: What, if anything, must now be decided so that the existing parenting arrangements can be implemented?
Sometimes nothing further requires a Parenting Coordinator decision. The arrangement is already clear and what is actually required is compliance with it. That is where the distinction between implementation and enforcement becomes particularly important.
When a Parenting Coordinator Determination May Still Be Appropriate
If an actual implementation dispute remains and the Parenting Coordinator has jurisdiction over it, the PC may assist the parents in attempting to resolve the issue and may make a determination where authorized if agreement is not reached.
The current BC statutory scheme separately recognizes Parenting Coordinator assistance under s. 17 and determinations under s. 18. Section 19 then provides the statutory mechanism for changing or setting aside determinations. A determination in these circumstances is not a consequence for earlier non-compliance. It is an implementation decision intended to provide the clarity or structure needed for the parenting arrangements to operate going forward.
Depending upon the particular parenting arrangements and the PC's jurisdiction, that might involve:
- clarifying practical implementation of an existing parenting term;
- establishing an authorized process for carrying out an existing arrangement;
- resolving an eligible implementation dispute that has arisen from differing interpretations or proposals; or
- addressing Parenting Coordination fees where reapportionment is expressly authorized and supported by the circumstances.
Jurisdiction must come first. Calling something an implementation problem does not create authority the Parenting Coordinator does not otherwise possess.
A Determination Is Not a Punishment for a Breach
This point deserves particular emphasis. If a parent did not follow an earlier agreement, the purpose of a new determination is not to impose a penalty for what happened. The purpose must remain tied to an implementation issue within the Parenting Coordinator's jurisdiction.
There should not be an endless sequence in which:
Agreement → Non-compliance → Determination → Non-compliance → Another determination about the previous determination
At some point there may be no new implementation question to decide.
If the applicable parenting arrangement or binding determination is already sufficiently clear and what is required is simply enforcement, a Parenting Coordinator cannot manufacture a new implementation dispute in order to exercise authority the PC does not possess.
When the Matter Requires Court Involvement
Court involvement may be necessary where the relief actually required is enforcement, variation of the parenting arrangements, reallocation of parental responsibilities, coercive relief or another exercise of judicial authority outside the Parenting Coordinator's jurisdiction.
That is different from saying that every failure to follow an agreement requires court. The correct question is: What remedy is now required?
If an implementation question remains within PC jurisdiction, Parenting Coordination may still be appropriate.
If the arrangement is already clear and a parent seeks a judicial remedy because it is not being followed, that is fundamentally different. The Parenting Coordinator does not acquire enforcement authority simply because continued non-compliance is frustrating, expensive or harmful to the operation of the parenting arrangements.
The Parenting Coordinator assists parents in carrying out existing parenting arrangements and may make binding determinations where the parents cannot agree, but does not fundamentally change those arrangements.
When the Underlying Parenting Structure May Be the Problem
Repeated implementation difficulties can eventually raise a larger question. Suppose the Parenting Coordinator has clarified the process, established structure and made authorized determinations when required, but ordinary parenting decisions continually return to professional dispute resolution. The issue may no longer be whether another determination can technically be made.
The deeper question may be whether the existing parenting structure continues to provide a workable way for this family to make and implement decisions.
A Parenting Coordinator cannot answer that question by fundamentally redesigning the parenting arrangements. Where the required solution involves changing the allocation of parental responsibilities or otherwise altering the underlying parenting architecture, the matter requires the appropriate legal process rather than an expansion of PC authority. This is one of the limits of Parenting Coordination.
Parenting Coordination Fees When Agreements Are Not Followed
Failure to follow an agreed implementation process can also generate additional Parenting Coordinator work. The PC may need to review communications, identify the operative terms, obtain information from both parents, clarify the implementation question, separate collateral matters, facilitate further consultation or determine an eligible dispute. That professional involvement creates fees.
Where fee reapportionment is authorized, the Parenting Coordinator may consider whether identifiable additional costs generated by the implementation issue should be allocated differently. The analysis should remain proportionate and connected to the additional professional work actually required.
Fee reapportionment is not punishment for breaching an agreement. It is a separate cost-allocation question.
This distinction matters. The Parenting Coordinator is not using money to enforce parenting arrangements. The PC is addressing responsibility for the cost of the Parenting Coordination process where the governing authority permits it.
Not Every Problem Requires the Parenting Coordinator
Parents can significantly reduce Parenting Coordination fees by using the process proportionately. When a problem first arises:
- Check the actual wording. Read the applicable agreement, order or determination before assuming it has been breached.
- Ask for clarification. Where safe and appropriate, identify the apparent inconsistency neutrally and ask the other parent for an explanation.
- Focus on implementation. Ask what needs to happen now rather than beginning with blame about what happened previously.
- Use the Parenting Coordinator where necessary. If a genuine implementation dispute remains and falls within the PC's jurisdiction, structured Parenting Coordination may provide an efficient route to resolution.
- Recognize when the remedy is judicial. If the real relief sought is enforcement, variation, coercive authority or a fundamental change to the parenting arrangements, obtain legal advice about the appropriate court process.
This sequence helps distinguish an implementation problem from an enforcement problem before significant professional costs accumulate.
The Parenting Coordinator Does Not Decide Every Consequence of Non-Compliance
One of the risks in high-conflict Parenting Coordination is that every disputed event can begin to generate another professional process. That is neither necessary nor proportionate.
The PC does not need to adjudicate every accusation that an agreement was breached. The PC needs to know enough to identify whether a present implementation issue exists, whether it falls within jurisdiction and what process is reasonably required to resolve it.
Sometimes the appropriate response is clarification. Sometimes it is consultation. Sometimes it is an authorized determination. Sometimes no further PC decision is required because the governing arrangement is already clear. And sometimes the remedy being sought belongs to the court.
The Central Distinction: Implementation or Enforcement?
Parents understandably experience the distinction between implementation and enforcement as technical. If the other parent is not doing what was agreed, the natural question is: “Why can't the Parenting Coordinator just make them do it?”
Because that is not the Parenting Coordinator's statutory role.
Parenting Coordination provides a structured mechanism for helping existing parenting arrangements work. It can resolve eligible implementation disputes without requiring parents to return to court over every disagreement. It can provide a binding determination where jurisdiction exists and agreement cannot be reached. But Parenting Coordination is not a parallel enforcement court.
That boundary protects the integrity of the process. It allows the Parenting Coordinator to provide structure and decisions within the authority actually conferred without assuming judicial powers that belong elsewhere.
The Bottom Line
An agreement reached through Parenting Coordination should not be treated as optional merely because it was reached outside court. Under s. 6 of the Family Law Act, agreements respecting family law disputes are binding on the parties subject to the Act, including where they have not been filed with a court. When an agreement is not followed, however, the next step depends upon what problem remains to be solved.
If the parties need assistance implementing the existing parenting arrangements and the issue falls within the Parenting Coordinator's lawful and delegated jurisdiction, Parenting Coordination may remain appropriate.
If the arrangement is already clear and the remedy required is enforcement, variation, coercive relief or a fundamental restructuring of parental responsibilities, the solution lies outside the Parenting Coordinator's implementation role. That is not a weakness in Parenting Coordination. It is the boundary that defines it.
This article provides general public legal information about Parenting Coordination in British Columbia. It is not legal advice. The authority of a Parenting Coordinator depends upon the Family Law Act, the Family Law Act Regulation, and the particular court order or agreement conferring jurisdiction. Parents seeking enforcement, variation or other legal remedies should obtain legal advice about their individual circumstances.
Written by Cori L. McGuire, a Parenting Coordinator since 2008 and a family law lawyer since 1998 in British Columbia. Cori has many other articles on the parenting coordination process including: The Joyce Model in Parenting Coordination, When the Process Becomes the Conflict, How PCs Manage Conflict, When a Co-operation Stops, and our public education website on PC Limits. Further reading by subject is also found in our Resource Library.
© 2026 Cori McGuire. All Rights Reserved. Proprietary Workflow.
